0.12/0.13 % Problem : theBenchmark.p : TPTP v0.0.0. Released v0.0.0. 0.12/0.14 % Command : do_CVC4 %s %d 0.14/0.35 % Computer : n004.cluster.edu 0.14/0.35 % Model : x86_64 x86_64 0.14/0.35 % CPU : Intel(R) Xeon(R) CPU E5-2620 v4 @ 2.10GHz 0.14/0.35 % Memory : 8042.1875MB 0.14/0.35 % OS : Linux 3.10.0-693.el7.x86_64 0.14/0.35 % CPULimit : 960 0.14/0.35 % WCLimit : 120 0.14/0.35 % DateTime : Thu Jul 2 08:23:43 EDT 2020 0.14/0.35 % CPUTime : 0.20/0.48 %----Proving TH0 0.20/0.49 ------- cvc4-thf casc j10 : /export/starexec/sandbox2/benchmark/theBenchmark.p at 960... 0.20/0.49 --- Run --uf-ho --ho-elim --no-ho-elim-store-ax --full-saturate-quant at 20... 0.71/0.90 % SZS status Theorem for theBenchmark 0.71/0.90 % SZS output start Proof for theBenchmark 0.71/0.90 (skolem (forall ((BOUND_VARIABLE_424 |u_(-> a Bool)|) (BOUND_VARIABLE_446 |u_(-> a Bool)|) (BOUND_VARIABLE_428 |u_(-> a Bool)|)) (= (= BOUND_VARIABLE_424 (ho_5 (ho_4 k_3 BOUND_VARIABLE_428) BOUND_VARIABLE_446)) (and (forall ((Xx a)) (or (not (ho_2 BOUND_VARIABLE_446 Xx)) (ho_2 BOUND_VARIABLE_424 Xx)) ) (forall ((BOUND_VARIABLE_434 |u_(-> a Bool)|) (BOUND_VARIABLE_378 a)) (or (not (forall ((Xx a)) (or (not (ho_2 BOUND_VARIABLE_446 Xx)) (ho_2 BOUND_VARIABLE_434 Xx)) )) (not (forall ((Xx a)) (or (not (ho_2 BOUND_VARIABLE_428 Xx)) (ho_2 BOUND_VARIABLE_434 Xx)) )) (not (ho_2 BOUND_VARIABLE_424 BOUND_VARIABLE_378)) (ho_2 BOUND_VARIABLE_434 BOUND_VARIABLE_378)) ) (forall ((Xx a)) (or (not (ho_2 BOUND_VARIABLE_428 Xx)) (ho_2 BOUND_VARIABLE_424 Xx)) ))) ) 0.71/0.90 ( skv_6 skv_7 skv_8 ) 0.71/0.90 ) 0.71/0.90 (skolem (forall ((z a)) (= (ho_2 skv_7 z) (ho_2 skv_8 z)) ) 0.71/0.90 ( skv_10 ) 0.71/0.90 ) 0.71/0.90 (skolem (forall ((Xx a)) (or (not (ho_2 skv_8 Xx)) (ho_2 skv_7 Xx)) ) 0.71/0.90 ( skv_11 ) 0.71/0.90 ) 0.71/0.90 (skolem (forall ((z |u_(-> a Bool)|)) (= (ho_5 (ho_4 k_3 skv_8) z) (ho_5 (ho_4 k_3 skv_6) z)) ) 0.71/0.90 ( skv_12 ) 0.71/0.90 ) 0.71/0.90 (skolem (forall ((Xx a)) (or (not (ho_2 skv_7 Xx)) (ho_2 (ho_5 (ho_4 k_3 skv_8) skv_7) Xx)) ) 0.71/0.90 ( skv_13 ) 0.71/0.90 ) 0.71/0.90 (skolem (forall ((Xx a)) (or (not (ho_2 skv_8 Xx)) (ho_2 (ho_5 (ho_4 k_3 skv_8) skv_7) Xx)) ) 0.71/0.90 ( skv_14 ) 0.71/0.90 ) 0.71/0.90 (skolem (forall ((Xx a)) (or (not (ho_2 skv_7 Xx)) (ho_2 skv_8 Xx)) ) 0.71/0.90 ( skv_15 ) 0.71/0.90 ) 0.71/0.90 (skolem (forall ((z a)) (= (ho_2 skv_7 z) (ho_2 (ho_5 (ho_4 k_3 skv_8) skv_7) z)) ) 0.71/0.90 ( skv_16 ) 0.71/0.90 ) 0.71/0.90 (skolem (forall ((Xx a)) (or (not (ho_2 skv_7 Xx)) (ho_2 (ho_5 (ho_4 k_3 skv_6) skv_6) Xx)) ) 0.71/0.90 ( skv_17 ) 0.71/0.90 ) 0.71/0.90 (skolem (forall ((Xx a)) (or (not (ho_2 skv_8 Xx)) (ho_2 (ho_5 (ho_4 k_3 skv_6) skv_6) Xx)) ) 0.71/0.90 ( skv_18 ) 0.71/0.90 ) 0.71/0.90 (skolem (forall ((z a)) (= (ho_2 skv_8 z) (ho_2 (ho_5 (ho_4 k_3 skv_8) skv_7) z)) ) 0.71/0.90 ( skv_19 ) 0.71/0.90 ) 0.71/0.90 (skolem (forall ((z |u_(-> a Bool)|)) (= (ho_5 (ho_4 k_3 skv_8) z) (ho_5 (ho_4 k_3 skv_7) z)) ) 0.71/0.90 ( skv_20 ) 0.71/0.90 ) 0.71/0.90 (skolem (forall ((Xx a)) (or (not (ho_2 skv_7 Xx)) (ho_2 (ho_5 (ho_4 k_3 skv_6) skv_7) Xx)) ) 0.71/0.90 ( skv_21 ) 0.71/0.90 ) 0.71/0.90 (skolem (forall ((Xx a)) (or (not (ho_2 skv_8 Xx)) (ho_2 (ho_5 (ho_4 k_3 skv_6) skv_7) Xx)) ) 0.71/0.90 ( skv_22 ) 0.71/0.90 ) 0.71/0.90 (skolem (forall ((z |u_(-> a Bool)|)) (= (ho_5 (ho_4 k_3 skv_6) z) (ho_5 (ho_4 k_3 skv_7) z)) ) 0.71/0.90 ( skv_23 ) 0.71/0.90 ) 0.71/0.90 (skolem (forall ((Xx a)) (or (not (ho_2 skv_7 Xx)) (ho_2 skv_12 Xx)) ) 0.71/0.90 ( skv_24 ) 0.71/0.90 ) 0.71/0.90 (skolem (forall ((z a)) (= (ho_2 skv_7 z) (ho_2 skv_6 z)) ) 0.71/0.90 ( skv_25 ) 0.71/0.90 ) 0.71/0.90 (skolem (forall ((z a)) (= (ho_2 skv_8 z) (ho_2 skv_6 z)) ) 0.71/0.90 ( skv_26 ) 0.71/0.90 ) 0.71/0.90 (skolem (forall ((z a)) (= (ho_2 (ho_5 (ho_4 k_3 skv_8) skv_7) z) (ho_2 skv_6 z)) ) 0.71/0.90 ( skv_27 ) 0.71/0.90 ) 0.71/0.90 (skolem (forall ((Xx a)) (or (not (ho_2 skv_7 Xx)) (ho_2 (ho_5 (ho_4 k_3 skv_6) skv_12) Xx)) ) 0.71/0.90 ( skv_28 ) 0.71/0.90 ) 0.71/0.90 (skolem (forall ((Xx a)) (or (not (ho_2 skv_8 Xx)) (ho_2 (ho_5 (ho_4 k_3 skv_6) skv_12) Xx)) ) 0.71/0.90 ( skv_29 ) 0.71/0.90 ) 0.71/0.90 (skolem (forall ((Xx a)) (or (not (ho_2 skv_7 Xx)) (ho_2 skv_6 Xx)) ) 0.71/0.90 ( skv_30 ) 0.71/0.90 ) 0.71/0.90 (skolem (forall ((Xx a)) (or (not (ho_2 skv_8 Xx)) (ho_2 skv_6 Xx)) ) 0.71/0.90 ( skv_31 ) 0.71/0.90 ) 0.71/0.90 (skolem (forall ((BOUND_VARIABLE_434 |u_(-> a Bool)|) (BOUND_VARIABLE_378 a)) (or (not (forall ((Xx a)) (or (not (ho_2 skv_7 Xx)) (ho_2 BOUND_VARIABLE_434 Xx)) )) (not (forall ((Xx a)) (or (not (ho_2 skv_8 Xx)) (ho_2 BOUND_VARIABLE_434 Xx)) )) (not (ho_2 skv_6 BOUND_VARIABLE_378)) (ho_2 BOUND_VARIABLE_434 BOUND_VARIABLE_378)) ) 0.71/0.90 ( skv_32 skv_33 ) 0.71/0.90 ) 0.71/0.90 (instantiation (forall ((BOUND_VARIABLE_482 |u_(-> a Bool)|) (BOUND_VARIABLE_479 |u_(-> a Bool)|) (BOUND_VARIABLE_413 a)) (= (ho_2 (ho_5 (ho_4 k_3 BOUND_VARIABLE_482) BOUND_VARIABLE_479) BOUND_VARIABLE_413) (or (ho_2 BOUND_VARIABLE_482 BOUND_VARIABLE_413) (ho_2 BOUND_VARIABLE_479 BOUND_VARIABLE_413))) ) 0.71/0.90 ( skv_6, skv_6, e_a_9 ) 0.71/0.90 ( skv_6, skv_6, skv_10 ) 0.71/0.90 ( skv_6, skv_6, skv_17 ) 0.71/0.90 ( skv_6, skv_6, skv_18 ) 0.71/0.90 ( skv_6, skv_6, skv_22 ) 0.71/0.90 ( skv_6, skv_6, skv_24 ) 0.71/0.90 ( skv_6, skv_6, skv_25 ) 0.71/0.90 ( skv_6, skv_6, skv_26 ) 0.71/0.90 ( skv_6, skv_6, skv_28 ) 0.71/0.90 ( skv_6, skv_7, e_a_9 ) 0.71/0.90 ( skv_6, skv_7, skv_10 ) 0.71/0.90 ( skv_6, skv_7, skv_21 ) 0.71/0.90 ( skv_6, skv_7, skv_22 ) 0.71/0.90 ( skv_6, skv_7, skv_24 ) 0.71/0.90 ( skv_6, skv_7, skv_25 ) 0.71/0.90 ( skv_6, skv_7, skv_26 ) 0.71/0.90 ( skv_6, skv_7, skv_28 ) 0.71/0.90 ( skv_6, skv_8, e_a_9 ) 0.71/0.90 ( skv_6, skv_12, skv_10 ) 0.71/0.90 ( skv_6, skv_12, skv_28 ) 0.71/0.90 ( skv_6, skv_12, skv_29 ) 0.71/0.90 ( skv_7, skv_6, e_a_9 ) 0.71/0.90 ( skv_7, skv_7, e_a_9 ) 0.71/0.90 ( skv_7, skv_8, e_a_9 ) 0.71/0.90 ( skv_8, skv_6, e_a_9 ) 0.71/0.90 ( skv_8, skv_7, e_a_9 ) 0.71/0.90 ( skv_8, skv_7, skv_10 ) 0.71/0.90 ( skv_8, skv_7, skv_13 ) 0.71/0.90 ( skv_8, skv_7, skv_14 ) 0.71/0.90 ( skv_8, skv_7, skv_16 ) 0.71/0.90 ( skv_8, skv_7, skv_17 ) 0.71/0.90 ( skv_8, skv_7, skv_18 ) 0.71/0.90 ( skv_8, skv_7, skv_19 ) 0.71/0.90 ( skv_8, skv_7, skv_22 ) 0.71/0.90 ( skv_8, skv_7, skv_24 ) 0.71/0.90 ( skv_8, skv_7, skv_25 ) 0.71/0.90 ( skv_8, skv_7, skv_26 ) 0.71/0.90 ( skv_8, skv_7, skv_27 ) 0.71/0.90 ( skv_8, skv_7, skv_28 ) 0.71/0.90 ( skv_8, skv_7, skv_30 ) 0.71/0.90 ( skv_8, skv_7, skv_31 ) 0.71/0.90 ( skv_8, skv_7, skv_33 ) 0.71/0.90 ( skv_8, skv_8, e_a_9 ) 0.71/0.90 ) 0.71/0.90 (instantiation (forall ((x |u_(-> a Bool)|) (y |u_(-> a Bool)|)) (or (not (forall ((z a)) (= (ho_2 x z) (ho_2 y z)) )) (= x y)) ) 0.71/0.90 ( skv_7, skv_6 ) 0.71/0.90 ( skv_7, skv_8 ) 0.71/0.90 ( skv_7, (ho_5 (ho_4 k_3 skv_8) skv_7) ) 0.71/0.90 ( skv_8, skv_6 ) 0.71/0.90 ( skv_8, skv_7 ) 0.71/0.90 ( skv_8, (ho_5 (ho_4 k_3 skv_8) skv_7) ) 0.71/0.90 ( (ho_5 (ho_4 k_3 skv_8) skv_7), skv_6 ) 0.71/0.90 ( (ho_5 (ho_4 k_3 skv_8) skv_7), skv_7 ) 0.71/0.90 ( (ho_5 (ho_4 k_3 skv_8) skv_7), skv_8 ) 0.71/0.90 ) 0.71/0.90 (instantiation (forall ((x |u_(-> _u_(-> a Bool)_ a Bool)|) (y |u_(-> _u_(-> a Bool)_ a Bool)|)) (or (not (forall ((z |u_(-> a Bool)|)) (= (ho_5 x z) (ho_5 y z)) )) (= x y)) ) 0.71/0.90 ( (ho_4 k_3 skv_8), (ho_4 k_3 skv_6) ) 0.71/0.90 ( (ho_4 k_3 skv_8), (ho_4 k_3 skv_7) ) 0.71/0.90 ( (ho_4 k_3 skv_6), (ho_4 k_3 skv_8) ) 0.71/0.90 ( (ho_4 k_3 skv_6), (ho_4 k_3 skv_7) ) 0.71/0.90 ( (ho_4 k_3 skv_7), (ho_4 k_3 skv_8) ) 0.71/0.90 ( (ho_4 k_3 skv_7), (ho_4 k_3 skv_6) ) 0.71/0.90 ) 0.71/0.90 (instantiation (forall ((Xx a)) (or (not (ho_2 skv_7 Xx)) (ho_2 skv_6 Xx)) ) 0.71/0.90 ( e_a_9 ) 0.71/0.90 ( skv_15 ) 0.71/0.90 ( skv_17 ) 0.71/0.90 ( skv_19 ) 0.71/0.90 ( skv_24 ) 0.71/0.90 ( skv_27 ) 0.71/0.90 ( skv_28 ) 0.71/0.90 ) 0.71/0.90 (instantiation (forall ((BOUND_VARIABLE_434 |u_(-> a Bool)|) (BOUND_VARIABLE_378 a)) (or (not (forall ((Xx a)) (or (not (ho_2 skv_7 Xx)) (ho_2 BOUND_VARIABLE_434 Xx)) )) (not (forall ((Xx a)) (or (not (ho_2 skv_8 Xx)) (ho_2 BOUND_VARIABLE_434 Xx)) )) (not (ho_2 skv_6 BOUND_VARIABLE_378)) (ho_2 BOUND_VARIABLE_434 BOUND_VARIABLE_378)) ) 0.71/0.90 ( skv_6, e_a_9 ) 0.71/0.90 ( skv_7, skv_10 ) 0.71/0.90 ( skv_7, skv_11 ) 0.71/0.90 ( skv_7, skv_13 ) 0.71/0.90 ( skv_7, skv_14 ) 0.71/0.90 ( skv_7, skv_16 ) 0.71/0.90 ( skv_7, skv_25 ) 0.71/0.90 ( skv_7, skv_26 ) 0.71/0.90 ( skv_8, skv_13 ) 0.71/0.90 ( skv_8, skv_14 ) 0.71/0.90 ( skv_8, skv_15 ) 0.71/0.90 ( skv_8, skv_19 ) 0.71/0.90 ( skv_8, skv_25 ) 0.71/0.90 ( skv_8, skv_26 ) 0.71/0.90 ( (ho_5 (ho_4 k_3 skv_8) skv_7), skv_10 ) 0.71/0.90 ( (ho_5 (ho_4 k_3 skv_8) skv_7), skv_13 ) 0.71/0.90 ( (ho_5 (ho_4 k_3 skv_8) skv_7), skv_14 ) 0.71/0.90 ( (ho_5 (ho_4 k_3 skv_8) skv_7), skv_25 ) 0.71/0.90 ( (ho_5 (ho_4 k_3 skv_8) skv_7), skv_26 ) 0.71/0.90 ( (ho_5 (ho_4 k_3 skv_8) skv_7), skv_27 ) 0.71/0.90 ( (ho_5 (ho_4 k_3 skv_6) skv_6), skv_10 ) 0.71/0.90 ( (ho_5 (ho_4 k_3 skv_6) skv_6), skv_17 ) 0.71/0.90 ( (ho_5 (ho_4 k_3 skv_6) skv_6), skv_18 ) 0.71/0.90 ( (ho_5 (ho_4 k_3 skv_6) skv_6), skv_25 ) 0.71/0.90 ( (ho_5 (ho_4 k_3 skv_6) skv_6), skv_26 ) 0.71/0.90 ( (ho_5 (ho_4 k_3 skv_6) skv_7), skv_10 ) 0.71/0.90 ( (ho_5 (ho_4 k_3 skv_6) skv_7), skv_22 ) 0.71/0.90 ( skv_12, skv_10 ) 0.71/0.90 ( skv_12, skv_11 ) 0.71/0.90 ( skv_12, skv_15 ) 0.71/0.90 ( skv_12, skv_16 ) 0.71/0.90 ( skv_12, skv_24 ) 0.71/0.90 ( (ho_5 (ho_4 k_3 skv_6) skv_12), skv_10 ) 0.71/0.90 ( (ho_5 (ho_4 k_3 skv_6) skv_12), skv_28 ) 0.71/0.90 ) 0.71/0.90 (instantiation (forall ((Xx a)) (or (not (ho_2 skv_8 Xx)) (ho_2 skv_6 Xx)) ) 0.71/0.90 ( e_a_9 ) 0.71/0.90 ( skv_10 ) 0.71/0.90 ( skv_11 ) 0.71/0.90 ( skv_16 ) 0.71/0.90 ( skv_17 ) 0.71/0.90 ( skv_18 ) 0.71/0.90 ( skv_21 ) 0.71/0.90 ( skv_22 ) 0.71/0.90 ( skv_24 ) 0.71/0.90 ( skv_27 ) 0.71/0.90 ( skv_28 ) 0.71/0.90 ( skv_29 ) 0.71/0.90 ) 0.71/0.90 (instantiation (forall ((Xx a)) (or (not (ho_2 skv_8 Xx)) (ho_2 skv_7 Xx)) ) 0.71/0.90 ( skv_10 ) 0.71/0.90 ) 0.71/0.90 (instantiation (forall ((Xx a)) (or (not (ho_2 skv_7 Xx)) (ho_2 (ho_5 (ho_4 k_3 skv_8) skv_7) Xx)) ) 0.71/0.90 ( skv_15 ) 0.71/0.90 ( skv_17 ) 0.71/0.90 ( skv_24 ) 0.71/0.90 ( skv_26 ) 0.71/0.90 ( skv_27 ) 0.71/0.90 ( skv_28 ) 0.71/0.90 ) 0.71/0.90 (instantiation (forall ((Xx a)) (or (not (ho_2 skv_8 Xx)) (ho_2 (ho_5 (ho_4 k_3 skv_8) skv_7) Xx)) ) 0.71/0.90 ( skv_11 ) 0.71/0.90 ( skv_17 ) 0.71/0.90 ( skv_18 ) 0.71/0.90 ( skv_22 ) 0.71/0.90 ( skv_24 ) 0.71/0.90 ( skv_25 ) 0.71/0.90 ( skv_27 ) 0.71/0.90 ( skv_28 ) 0.71/0.90 ( skv_29 ) 0.71/0.90 ) 0.71/0.90 (instantiation (forall ((Xx a)) (or (not (ho_2 skv_7 Xx)) (ho_2 skv_8 Xx)) ) 0.71/0.90 ( skv_19 ) 0.71/0.90 ) 0.71/0.90 (instantiation (forall ((Xx a)) (or (not (ho_2 skv_7 Xx)) (ho_2 (ho_5 (ho_4 k_3 skv_6) skv_6) Xx)) ) 0.71/0.90 ( skv_15 ) 0.71/0.90 ( skv_18 ) 0.71/0.90 ( skv_19 ) 0.71/0.90 ( skv_24 ) 0.71/0.90 ( skv_26 ) 0.71/0.90 ( skv_28 ) 0.71/0.90 ) 0.71/0.90 (instantiation (forall ((Xx a)) (or (not (ho_2 skv_8 Xx)) (ho_2 (ho_5 (ho_4 k_3 skv_6) skv_6) Xx)) ) 0.71/0.90 ( skv_11 ) 0.71/0.90 ( skv_16 ) 0.71/0.90 ( skv_22 ) 0.71/0.90 ( skv_24 ) 0.71/0.90 ( skv_25 ) 0.71/0.90 ( skv_28 ) 0.71/0.90 ( skv_29 ) 0.71/0.90 ) 0.71/0.90 (instantiation (forall ((Xx a)) (or (not (ho_2 skv_7 Xx)) (ho_2 (ho_5 (ho_4 k_3 skv_6) skv_7) Xx)) ) 0.71/0.90 ( skv_15 ) 0.71/0.90 ( skv_19 ) 0.71/0.90 ( skv_22 ) 0.71/0.90 ( skv_24 ) 0.71/0.90 ( skv_26 ) 0.71/0.90 ( skv_28 ) 0.71/0.90 ) 0.71/0.90 (instantiation (forall ((Xx a)) (or (not (ho_2 skv_8 Xx)) (ho_2 (ho_5 (ho_4 k_3 skv_6) skv_7) Xx)) ) 0.71/0.90 ( skv_11 ) 0.71/0.90 ( skv_16 ) 0.71/0.90 ( skv_24 ) 0.71/0.90 ( skv_25 ) 0.71/0.90 ( skv_28 ) 0.71/0.90 ( skv_29 ) 0.71/0.90 ) 0.71/0.90 (instantiation (forall ((Xx a)) (or (not (ho_2 skv_7 Xx)) (ho_2 skv_12 Xx)) ) 0.71/0.90 ( skv_15 ) 0.71/0.90 ( skv_19 ) 0.71/0.90 ( skv_26 ) 0.71/0.90 ) 0.71/0.90 (instantiation (forall ((z a)) (= (ho_2 (ho_5 (ho_4 k_3 skv_8) skv_7) z) (ho_2 skv_6 z)) ) 0.71/0.90 ( skv_24 ) 0.71/0.90 ) 0.71/0.90 (instantiation (forall ((Xx a)) (or (not (ho_2 skv_7 Xx)) (ho_2 (ho_5 (ho_4 k_3 skv_6) skv_12) Xx)) ) 0.71/0.90 ( skv_15 ) 0.71/0.90 ( skv_19 ) 0.71/0.90 ( skv_26 ) 0.71/0.90 ( skv_29 ) 0.71/0.90 ) 0.71/0.90 (instantiation (forall ((Xx a)) (or (not (ho_2 skv_8 Xx)) (ho_2 (ho_5 (ho_4 k_3 skv_6) skv_12) Xx)) ) 0.71/0.90 ( skv_11 ) 0.71/0.90 ( skv_16 ) 0.71/0.90 ( skv_25 ) 0.71/0.90 ( skv_28 ) 0.71/0.90 ( skv_29 ) 0.71/0.90 ) 0.71/0.90 (instantiation (forall ((Xx a)) (or (not (ho_2 skv_7 Xx)) (ho_2 skv_32 Xx)) ) 0.71/0.90 ( skv_15 ) 0.71/0.90 ( skv_19 ) 0.71/0.90 ( skv_26 ) 0.71/0.90 ( skv_33 ) 0.71/0.90 ) 0.71/0.90 (instantiation (forall ((Xx a)) (or (not (ho_2 skv_8 Xx)) (ho_2 skv_32 Xx)) ) 0.71/0.90 ( skv_10 ) 0.71/0.90 ( skv_11 ) 0.71/0.90 ( skv_16 ) 0.71/0.90 ( skv_25 ) 0.71/0.90 ( skv_29 ) 0.71/0.90 ( skv_33 ) 0.71/0.90 ) 0.71/0.90 % SZS output end Proof for theBenchmark 0.71/0.90 EOF